|
State Groups Were Formed After 9/11
Intelligence centers run by states across the country have access to
personal information about millions of Americans, including unlisted
cellphone numbers, insurance claims, driver's license photographs and
credit reports, according to a document obtained by The Washington Post.
One center also has access to top-secret data systems at the CIA, the document shows, though it's not clear what information those systems contain.
Dozens
of the organizations known as fusion centers were created after the
Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks to identify potential threats and
improve the way information is shared. The centers use law enforcement
analysts and sophisticated computer systems to compile, or fuse,
disparate tips and clues and pass along the refined information to
other agencies. They are expected to play important roles in national
information-sharing networks that link local, state and federal
authorities and enable them to automatically sift their storehouses of
records for patterns and clues.
Though officials have publicly
discussed the fusion centers' importance to national security, they
have generally declined to elaborate on the centers' activities. But a
document that lists resources used by the fusion centers shows how a
dozen of the organizations in the northeastern United States rely far
more on access to commercial and government databases than had
previously been disclosed.
Those details have come to light at a
time of debate about domestic intelligence efforts, including
eavesdropping and data-aggregation programs at the National Security Agency, and whether the government has enough protections in place to prevent abuses.
The
list of information resources was part of a survey conducted last year,
officials familiar with the effort said. It shows that, like most
police agencies, the fusion centers have subscriptions to private
information-broker services that keep records about Americans'
locations, financial holdings, associates, relatives, firearms licenses
and the like.
Centers serving New York and other states also tap into a Federal Trade Commission database with information about hundreds of thousands of identity-theft reports, the document and police interviews show.
Pennsylvania buys credit reports and uses face-recognition software to examine driver's license photos, while analysts in Rhode Island have access to car-rental databases. In Maryland,
authorities rely on a little-known data broker called Entersect, which
claims it maintains 12 billion records about 98 percent of Americans.
In
its online promotional material, Entersect calls itself "the silent
partner to municipal, county, state, and federal justice agencies who
access our databases every day to locate subjects, develop background
information, secure information from a cellular or unlisted number, and
much more."
Police officials said fusion center analysts are
trained to use the information responsibly, legally and only on
authorized criminal and counterterrorism cases. They stressed the
importance of secret and public data in rooting out obscure threats.
"There
is never ever enough information when it comes to terrorism" said Maj.
Steven G. O'Donnell, deputy superintendent of the Rhode Island State
Police. "That's what post-9/11 is about."
Government watchdogs,
along with some police and intelligence officials, said they worry that
the fusion centers do not have enough oversight and are not open enough
with the public, in part because they operate under various state rules.
"Fusion
centers have grown, really, off the radar screen of public
accountability," said Jim Dempsey, vice president for public policy at
the Center for Democracy and Technology, a nonpartisan watchdog group
in the District. "Congress and the state legislatures need to get a
handle over what is going on at all these fusion centers."
Fusion
centers were formed in the wake of revelations that counterterrorism
and law enforcement authorities missed or neglected evidence that the
Sept. 11 attackers were in the United States while preparing to strike.
Because
they are organized by the states, the centers have developed in
different ways. Some are small operations focused on crime, while
others are full-fledged criminal and counterterrorism operations. From
2004 to 2007, state and local governments received $254 million from
the Department of Homeland Security in support of the centers, which are also supported by employees of the FBI and other federal law enforcement agencies. In some cases, they work with the U.S. Northern Command, the Pentagon operation involved in homeland security.
The
centers have been criticized for being secretive, but authorities said
that this is largely for security reasons. Activists want to know more
about their activities, the kinds of information they collect and how
the information is being used.
The Electronic Privacy Information Center filed a lawsuit in Virginia
last month seeking the release of records about communication among
state fusion center officials and the departments of Homeland Security
and Justice. Marc Rotenberg,
the privacy center's executive director, said his group was responding
to a proposed state law that would sharply limit access to records
about the fusion centers' activity.
Sue Reingold, deputy program
manager in the Information Sharing Environment office, a federal
operation with a mandate to improve information sharing, said state and
local officials "must have access to a broad array of classified and
unclassified information" to perform their mission. But Reingold said
that an "important part of this is appropriate training and oversight
that is well understood and transparent to the public."
"Fusion centers are vital to state and local efforts to fight crime, including terrorism," she said.
The list includes a wide variety of data resources along with software that finds patterns and displays links among people.
Most of the centers have subscriptions to Accurint, ChoicePoint's Autotrack or LexisNexis.
These information brokers are Web-based services that deliver instant
access to billions of records on individuals' homes, cars, phone
numbers and other information.
Some of the centers link to
records of currency transactions and almost 5 million
suspicious-activity reports filed by financial institutions with the
Treasury Department's Financial Crimes Enforcement Network.
Massachusetts
and other states rely on LocatePlus, an information broker that claims
that it provides "the most comprehensive cell phone, unlisted and
unpublished phone database in the industry." The state also taps a
private system called ClaimSearch that includes a "nationwide database
that provides information on insurance claims, including vehicles,
casualty claims and property claims," the document said.
The center in Ohio has access, through authorized users, to an FBI "secret level repository," the document said.
Rhode
Island reported that it has access, also through the FBI, to "Top
Secret resources" such as "Proton, which allows queries of CIA
databases," the document shows. Officials at the Rhode Island State
Police, FBI and CIA declined to discuss the system and the kinds of
information it contains.
In addition to databases run by
Entersect, Maryland fusion center analysts have access to wage and
property records, corporate charters, utility records and a host of
government files, including criminal justice information and traffic
tickets. Jason Luckenbaugh, the center's chief of staff, acknowledged
concern about the government's ability to tap into new sources of
information. But he said the databases enable analysts to fight crime
and protect against terrorism, and help local authorities do the same.
"We're not trying to threaten them in any way," he said.
Here is the information on the Virginia Lawsuit:
EPIC Sues to Compel Disclosure of Documents About Federal Role in
Virginia Secrecy Bill
Today, EPIC filed a Virginia Freedom of Information Act lawsuit (pdf) challenging the Virginia State Police's failure to make public
documents relating to the role of federal agencies in recent legislative
efforts to limit the state's open government and privacy laws for "fusion
centers." These intelligence databases collect information on ordinary
citizens and have raised substantial privacy concerns. Press
reports and statements from Virginia officials have raised
questions about federal involvement in the Virginia legislation. The
lawsuit follows EPIC's original requests (pdf). For more
information,
see EPIC's page Information Fusion Centers and Privacy . (Mar. 21)
This is what Kurt Nimmo Reported
Call it Stasi, the American version, circa 2008. “The government is
rounding up your cell phone numbers, insurance claims, credit reports,
financial records, and the names of your associates and relatives and
sharing them with law enforcement officials nationwide,” reports John Byrne
for Raw Story. “So-called ‘fusion centers’ set up after the Sept. 11,
2001 attacks collect, store and analyze commercial and public data on
unknown millions of Americans. Little is known about the centers,
though they received $254 million from the Department of Homeland
Security between 2004 and 2007.”
In East Germany before our rulers decided the Berlin Wall must fall,
the Stasi did much the same, although they didn’t have the
sophisticated technology available to the mysterious “fusion centers”
in the United States. But the idea was exactly the same — to ferret out
dissidents and compile dossiers on every aspect of their lives.
The Ministry of Homeland Security, the FBI, the Pentagon, the CIA,
the NSA — these folks are not interested in the coming and goings of
apolitical Joe Sixpack, who is not a threat to the state. And the
“fusion centers” are not gathering info on al-Qaeda — blond hair and
blue eyes or otherwise — because there is no such thing, or only such a
thing when the government decides it is time to scare witless adults
and small children. No, the target here, as decades-long revelations
about the FBI demonstrate, are people involved in the antiwar movement,
the so-called patriot movement, environmentalists not funded by the
Ford and Rockefeller foundations, that is to say anybody and everybody
opposed to the government and not part of the fake opposition.
John Byrne continues:
Documents obtained by the Washington Post’s Robert
O’Harrow Jr. for Wednesday’s papers reveal that the centers — which
have flown beneath the public’s radar — have information that now
includes unlisted cell phone numbers, insurance claims, driver’s
license photographs, credit reports and even top-secret data systems at
the CIA.
“Dozens of the organizations known as fusion centers were created
after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks to identify potential
threats and improve the way information is shared,” O’Harrow says. “The
centers use law enforcement analysts and sophisticated computer systems
to compile, or fuse, disparate tips and clues and pass along the
refined information to other agencies. They are expected to play
important roles in national information-sharing networks that link
local, state and federal authorities and enable them to automatically
sift their storehouses of records for patterns and clues.”
(…)
The fusion centers also have subscriptions to information systems that provide information on Americans’ locations, financial holdings, associates, relatives and firearms licenses. (emphasis mine)
And why would the government — from the Pentagon, FBI, CIA down to
the local cops — want to know your location and if you own firearms? It
wouldn’t be because they may eventually decide you need to be rounded
up and put in a special camp, would it? It wouldn’t have anything to do
with a Katrina-styled door-to-door search for guns? It’s a heck of a
lot easier to confiscate your weapons and violate the Second Amendment
if the cops and mercenaries — excuse me, “contractors” — know where you
are at all times, who you associate with, and where your guns are.
It’s a rhetorical question, of course. Government always, without
exception, has a keen interest in keeping an eye on the opposition and,
as the historical record shows, this obsession invariably leads to
tyranny and concentration camps.
Here is a video talking about FLORIDA's Fusion Center
|